Season 2, Episode 5 REVIEW
– – Joe, Lily, Emma – –
The episode opens with Joe Carroll shaving his beard. Looking good! He shares a drink with Lily but they don’t talk about anything important.
Lily introduces Joe to the rest of the people living in her house. He seems surprised to learn about the twins, Luke and Mark. An angry Emma watches from the background, but she finally gets a moment alone with Joe. She asks why he never tried to find her, why did he abandon her and leave her all alone, why didn’t he tell her that he would fake his death? Joe says that he failed her and he is sorry, but Emma quietly walks away.
Once again the FBI works wonders with surveillance cameras, and they see footage of Ryan fighting Giselle, and then Max getting on the train. Now Agent Mendez wants the FBI to call local officials in Connecticut.
FBI learns about Judy in Arkansas, along with the missing pastor and the missing daughter, Mandy.
Joe and Emma meet up again, and he apologizes again. He asks Emma to trust Lily but Emma says ‘They are all crazy.’ Joe says he has a plan for them to start over. Meanwhile, Lily asks Mark to keep Emma busy. She wants to spend some time with Joe without Emma lurking around.
Mark takes Emma to a room where they can paint. Emma starts a portrait of Mark and then he walks over and strokes her face. She gently touches his face but then he freaks out and tells her that she can’t touch him without permission. Emma gets angry and tries to leave but finds that Mark locked them in the room.
Lily has kidnapped and sedated a young college woman, and she presents the woman to Joe as an offering. There are torture tools nearby. Joe is disgusted and walks out of the room.
Joe tells Lily that he will not be controlled. Then he goes to the room where the college girl is being held and he kills her. Afterwards he goes to Lily’s room and has sex with her.
Emma finishes her portrait of Mark, but a close look shows Mark’s body with Joe’s face.
– – Max, Ryan, and Gisele – –
Max follows Gisele off the train. Gisele calls Luke and tells him about Ryan and Max trying to detain her. She says she’ll hide out at the factory. He tells her not to worry and he’ll pick her up soon.
Ryan is driving to the station and tells Max to not follow Giselle. Of course Max doesn’t listen.
Ryan and Max corner Giselle and forcibly take her to a motel room. Ryan tells Giselle that she needs to start talking and give up Lily’s location. Giselle spits in Ryan’s face and he chokes her.
Max starts to call her FBI colleagues and then Gisele gives up the location of the factory, claiming that’s where Lily and the twins are. Max wants to be Ryan’s backup but he demands that she stay with Giselle and he’ll go alone to the factory.
Gisele is handcuffed, and she injures her hand as she forces it out of the cuff. She starts heading to the factory.
Luke arrives at the factory with one of the guys from Lily’s house. He engages in a shootout with Ryan. Ryan gets hit by a bullet and he kills Luke’s partner before running away.
Gisele arrives and meets with Luke. They run into the woods to track down Ryan and kill him.
Ryan finds a house where he can quickly nurse his wound but Luke and Gisele show up a little bit later. Gisele taunts Ryan and says she killed Max, and Ryan stabs her to death. Luke shoots after Ryan but he misses, and Ryan is able to escape while Luke mourns for Giselle.
We finish up the scene from the season 1 finale. Joe’s follower stabs Ryan and Claire, stabs Claire a second time and then Ryan kills her.
Mike Weston visits Ryan at the hospital and tells him that Claire died from her injuries.
– ONE YEAR LATER –
Ryan seems to be in good health. He’s going to AA meetings. We meet his sponsor, Barry, and another AA member, Melissa. He’s also a teacher.
His niece, Max, comes over to keep him company during the 1 year anniversary of Havenport/Joe’s death/Claire’s death. There’s a party with the niece, her boyfriend, Barry, and Melissa.
On a subway train three people in Joe Carroll masks appear and start stabbing and killing the passengers. One person yells, “The resurrection is coming! Joe Carroll lives! Ryan Hardy can’t stop us!”
Mike Weston is at home, far away from New York. He was suspended awhile ago, but Agent Phillips has asked him to come back to New York and investigate the subway killings.
A young woman, Heather, is walking to her apartment door and shares flirtatious glances with a young man hanging around. He strangles her to death and lays in bed with her.
– Flashback to 8 months ago, the last time Ryan and Mike saw each other – Ryan is drunk at the bar. Mike tells him Joey is safe with his grandmother in witness protection. It’s almost time to testify before the grand jury, and Mike begs Ryan to not talk, and just say “I don’t remember” to all of the questions.
Lily Gray survived the subway attack and she talks to the FBI agents, Mike, and Ryan.
Crazy guy cooks food and dances with Heather’s dead body. Wait…there’s two! He has a twin.
Emma is in New Jersey wearing a punk, multi-color hairdo and lip piercings. She’s stunned by the attacks.
At FBI HQ, Mike uses a body scan on the surveillance footage and IDs a guy named Carlos. Agents Phillips and Mendez are trying to get Ryan’s help but he is very resistant and he leaves.
Ryan sits down with Max and goes through his case notes. Looks like these two have been working for awhile to track down Carroll. Ryan finds some information about Carlos. Max locates his most recent home address and Ryan goes to pay a visit. He doesn’t call the FBI.
Carlos says Joe escaped unharmed from the lighthouse. He was going to drive Joe away but the police road blocks caused Joe to flee the car and go off into the darkness.
After a brief scuffle Carlos gets away from Ryan and runs to Giselle’s apartment. Ryan searches Carlos’ apartment and finds a playbill with Heather’s name circled on it. He calls Max and she tells him a young woman was found dead. Emma is following Ryan and she watches him leave the apartment building.
Mike confronts Ryan at the crime scene for secluding himself after the events at the lighthouse. Heather’s body is tied to a bench with a book taped to her hands, and she’s wearing a light white dress and red lips. This is a Claire-like character from Joe’s book.
The crazy twins (Luke with the slicked back hair and Mark with the bangs) visit Carlos at Giselle’s apartment. They are worried that Ryan found some incriminating evidence at his apartment. Turns out the twins are followers of Joe Carroll but they are leaders of a rogue group that has no connection to Emma and her people.
In the last scene we see Joe Carroll walk into a random prostitute’s home. A young girl in the house calls him ‘Darryl’. He lives!
The FBI moves in, and Carroll starts the escape plan
With Joey Matthews in the FBI’s custody, he has given them a detailed description of the Crazy House. The FBI starts house hunting.
Carroll is still suffering from his deep stab wound and he is becoming very erratic in his thoughts and behavior. With Roderick gone he tries to lean on Emma’s support. She is still wary of him after he slapped her recently.
Carroll decides to enact his getaway plan and he enlists the help of Emma, Jacob and a couple other followers. Jacob doesn’t seem too confident of Carroll’s ability to lead the followers but he goes with the plan anyways.
The FBI finds the dead body of a follower hanging inside the empty Crazy House. Meanwhile, Jacob, Emma, Carroll, and Claire have invaded the home of Vicki Gray and her husband in Havenport, Maryland.
Crazy finds the FBI
The FBI searches the empty house and Ryan finds a note: Dear Ryan, the final chapter has begun.
Back at the Gray’s residence, Carroll and the team are hiding out until nightfall. Jacob says he feels uncomfortable and when he joined the cult he thought it would just be him and Emma.
Outside the FBI headquarters a couple followers have arrived and joined the crowd of news reporters. Ryan goes outside because he thinks they might be there but he can’t identify them. One follower starts doing an interview with a local news reporter and starts quoting ‘The Masque of the Red Death’, then the follower stabs the reporter and gets taken down by Ryan.
Dinner with the Grays
Ryan talks to ‘Annabelle Lee’ and demands to know where Claire is. He flips a table and puts a gun to the woman’s head. She says Claire has to die so Ryan can be reborn.
Carroll has cooked a pasta dinner for everyone. Claire asks Carroll to spare the Grays’ lives and have them deliver a message to Ryan. Carroll said a message is already being delivered.
Emma apologizes to Jacob and says she wishes she could make things right. Jacob kisses and holds her and says everything will be okay.
Claire hurts Carroll again
Two police officers are checking out the neighborhood and they arrive at the Grays’ residence. Emma answers the door, and one of the officers hesitates after he realizes she doesn’t live in the home. She shoots the officers. In the dining room, Carroll untied Claire so she could pour some wine. When he gets distracted by Emma’s gunshots, she hits him over the head, stabs him in his wound with a knife, frees the Grays and runs off with them.
Ryan, Parker and Weston are trying to figure out why The Masque of the Red Death is so prominent with Carroll and his followers. Weston concludes the followers are planning a mass death at a place where people may seek refuge – the local evacuation center. Some of them may be followers so the FBI goes in to do a sweep.
The plan is set into motion.
Mayhem breaks out. Ryan makes eye contact with a guy he saw earlier outside of the FBI center. The guy gives a signal and the followers start attacking everyone nearby. The FBI shoots down some followers while Ryan chases down the guy he recognized. Parker gets trapped by two followers.
Claire and the Grays are running but they are tracked down by Jacob and Emma. They capture Claire and let the other two run free.
With the FBI distracted at the evacuation center, Carroll arrives at a boat with Claire, Emma, and Jacob. He boards with Claire and heads to sea, while Emma and Jacob get back into the car. He tells Emma that they should escape, instead of sticking around and eventually dying for Carroll. Emma says ‘I love you, and I love Joe, but I don’t know how to love you both.’ She slits Jacob’s throat and he dies.
Weston notices Parker is missing. She was captured by two followers who have dragged her into an empty coffin. They nail it shut and start piling dirt on top of the coffin as Parker screams from inside.
Yes, this a recap which means – spoilers!
Weston sees Roderick
In Maryland, Ryan and Parker are talking to Roderick about finding Carroll. They are coming up with a ‘game plan.’
Weston is walking around the sheriff’s office and he recognizes Roderick as one of the followers who orchestrated his beating. Weston pulls out a gun but he’s taken down by other officers while Roderick calmly walks out.
Roderick’s real name is Tim Nelson. Parker pulls up his entire history and she figures out Carroll was his advisor in school.
The media arrives and Ryan holds an unauthorized press conference. He says any follower who gives up the Crazy House location while receive full immunity for their crimes. He says it’s first come, first serve.
What’s the game plan, Carroll?
Roderick runs to the Crazy House and tells Carroll the bad news. Roderick thinks Carroll is hiding a plan from him, and he says he’s on the front lines every day protecting the following while Carroll writes a book and pines after an ex-wife who doesn’t want him anymore.
Carroll starts choking him but lets go, and Roderick wonders if Carroll will actually kill him one day. After Carroll and the followers watch Ryan’s press conference, Roderick kidnaps Joey and leaves the Crazy House.
The Followers are too late…
Carroll sends Jacob, Michael, and Ethan to find and KILL Roderick, and bring Joey home safely. Claire begs Jacob to find Joey and keep him far away from the Crazy House.
Weston gets a report that Roderick was seen getting into a waitress’ car. The car gets pulled over and Roderick shoots the two officers. He’s about to kill the waitress but he gets surrounded by the FBI and they take him into custody.
Time for negotiations
Of course Roderick wants to make a deal with Ryan, and he says that he kidnapped Joey Matthews as collateral, so he won’t be killed by Carroll. Ryan uses Roderick’s phone to call Carroll, and Carroll says he’ll personally peel the skin from Roderick’s body if Joey is hurt.
Roderick says he’ll hand over Joey to the FBI if they let him go free. Nick Donovan says ‘hell no’ to that and the FBI will find a different way to find Joey.
Roderick makes good on his part of the deal
Ryan sneaks Roderick out of the FBI office! The deal is Roderick leads Ryan to Joey, and then he can go free. Ryan dumps his weapons and his cell phone behind (as requested by Roderick) before driving away from the facility. Jacob and his crew discreetly follow Ryan’s police car.
Ryan and Roderick go into a house and Ryan pulls Joey out of a closet. Weston was hiding in the trunk the whole time and he calls Nick and Parker and then heads inside just in time to see Roderick pull a gun on Ryan. Roderick is shot and killed, but Weston didn’t pull the trigger…
Emma faces Carroll’s wrath
Emma starts freaking out and asks Carroll about their safety. She tries to snuggle up to him and he reminds her that all they have is sex, and nothing more. He accuses her of being neglectful and allowing Joey out of her eyesight. He slaps her when she talks back.
Ryan to the rescue
Jacob and his crew head closer to the house and eventually they come inside and start fighting with Ryan and Weston. Michael and Ethan are killed while Jacob tries to run off with Joey, but he’s stopped by Ryan. Jacob runs away and leaves Joey behind.
Carroll’s day goes from bad to worse
Emma and Jacob talk. He says they are going to die soon. Claire talks to Carroll and says she’ll stay and she’ll do whatever he wants, under one condition – don’t try to bring Joey back into the Crazy House. She said she will love him again but it will take time. They start to kiss and Claire stabs him in the abdomen before she’s dragged away by some followers.
A drunken and injured Carroll calls Ryan and says that it’s time for Claire to die.
A woman named Melissa arrives at the FBI office. She’s a follower and wants to take Ryan’s deal. Nick attempts to take her to a holding room but she stabs him in the eye with her hair ornament, and then she is shot dead by the surrounding officers.
Claire tries to escape with Joey. She arrives at the locked gate and she’s confronted by Roderick and the rest of the followers. He brings them back inside the house and fits Claire with an ankle monitor.
Mike Weston is back on the job and he’s at the armory with the rest of the team. Weston has a sketch of Roderick.
Parker analyzes some drawings on the walls of the armory. She comes up with ‘Carrollism’ to describe the religion that Carroll is using on his followers.
Carroll calls Ryan and asks ‘What motivates you? Who are you?’ Ryan asks if Carroll is upset that the FBI has found the armory, and Carroll hangs up on him.
1983 flashback – a teenage Ryan sits in the car while his father goes into a convenience store.
FBI finds a connection to Daniel Monroe, a black market arms dealer who’s been on the FBI radar for years due to his involvement with a militia group called Freedom 13. They suspect Carroll reached out to him to develop a heavy militant presence in his following.
Vince tells Carroll that the FBI will find everything they need in the armory, and they can trace the weapons to Daniel and possibly find the Crazy House, which Daniel helped them acquire. On the other hand, Roderick is convinced that the FBI won’t find Daniel or the Crazy House. Carroll decides he’ll kill Daniel, and he’s bringing Vince and Jacob as backup.
Mike is getting restless and snippy with Ryan. He jumps on a lead to Maryland, where a member of Freedom 13 lives. He arrives at the home with Parker and Ryan, and he breaks in and then attacks Bryan Fuller. Ryan continues to look around and he finds Daniel Monroe.
Parker handcuffs Bryan and leaves the room to make a call. Jacob slits Bryan’s throat and then he knocks Parker upside the head when she comes back into the room.
Emma tries to talk Claire about…something. She says Joey was safe in her care. Claire and Emma slap each other and then Claire starts choking Emma. Roderick breaks it up.
At the Fuller house, Ryan and Weston are questioning Daniel in a small room. Ryan leaves to check a noise and he ends up running into Vince and killing him. He goes back to the small room and the door is shut and locked with Carroll and Weston inside. Weston is tied up and Carroll starts hitting him and choking him.
Parker comes to her senses and finds herself tied up. Jacob tells her she’s going to die.
Carroll demands that Ryan repeats the story of how his father died.
1983 flashback – teenage Ryan hears gunshots inside the convenience store. He gets out of the car and sees the gunman, who stares at him and then runs away. Ryan runs into the store and watches his father die. He says a few days later the police found the gunman’s body after he overdosed.
Carroll tells Ryan, “Death motivates me, and it fuels me.” Jacob brings Parker to the small room, throws her at Ryan, and then he quickly runs off with Carroll. Ryan chases them but he can’t catch them.
Carroll is back at the Crazy House and he talks to Claire. She tells him that his shenanigans and his book are things he will have to pay for.
Jacob is watching TV and he sees his face plastered all over TV. He calls his dad to say ‘hello’ but then he hangs up.
Carroll and Emma start making out in the kitchen, and he apologizes for ignoring her.
We find out that Ryan held his father’s killer at gunpoint and forced the man to overdose.
Parker and Ryan meet with the local sherrif, and they tell him that they believe Carroll is in the area. The sheriff is – Roderick!
After a morning run Carroll calls Ryan with taunts about him losing Claire. He tells Ryan that he’s going to enjoy spending time with his reunited family.
Claire arrives at the Crazy House and she’s greeted by Jacob who escorts her to her room. She asks to see Joey but it’s not time yet and she’s locked in her room.
2009 flashback. Molly meets Carroll in prison. She’s an RN and she’s killed a lot of people in the terminal ward. Carroll asks her to follow Ryan Hardy.
Present day. Carroll and Molly are talking. She’s brought him papers and files that documents everything she picked up on Ryan Hardy. They broke up awhile ago but occasionally have sex.
Roderick confronts Carroll about ‘getting started.’ Apparently Joe said once he’s reunited with his family the followers can move forward with their plans but now he wants to delay the movement.
Parker stops by Ryan’s home and tells him that he can’t keep disappearing. She shows him the online recruiting site, and asks Ryan to continue helping the FBI.
FBI track the bandwidth for the site that holds the recruiting video. They are looking for Haley Mercury at a night club. Inside, Parker and Ryan comes across rooms with people tied up, BDSM style. They find a lady who is trying to delete the computer files.
* * * * *
Parker and Ryan talk to Haley and she gives them the scoop on Vince. She promises to deliver Vince if she can avoid a long jail sentence. Haley emails Vince and asks him to stop by. Ryan and Parker find some of his bomb materials.
Vince tells Roderick that he’s going out to make a drop. He tries to pat Roderick on the back and Roderick pulls a gun on him. Vince pulls out his gun and apologizes, then leaves. Roderick starts laughing and then he elbows a follower who is in the room with him.
Jacob brings some fancy clothes for Claire to wear. She tries to escape from her room and he throws her to the ground. He says Carroll has given permission to hurt her if needed.
Emma is still trying to convince Jacob that she loves him. He tells her ‘The Jacob that you love isn’t here.’
* * * * *
Claire is all dressed up and she finally meets with Carroll.
Vince stops by the fetish club to pick up his package and Haley is wearing a wire. She helps him to his car, and he forces her into his car by gunpoint. He says the FBI will be there soon to pick her up. Parker and Ryan fight about whether to take Vince down now, or follow him– they decide to follow him.
* * * * *
Vince takes Haley to an old military armory. He says it’s used to condition people and teach them how to kill. Parker calls SWAT to swoop in and secure the perimeter. Vince has found the wire and starts beating her. Ryan and Parker run inside, and of course they are alone. They find Haley but Vince has fled.
* * * * *
Haley is very upset because she kept saying the rescue word ‘Red’ and the FBI never came to help her. She could’ve died and Parker says ‘But you didn’t.’
SWAT and FBI have arrived at the armory and they have opened one of the cages to free some people. Parker and Ryan warn them to not open any cages because they hold cult members, but it’s too late and some people have been freed. Ryan finds a few of them and shoots them down.
Dinner between Carroll and Claire isn’t going well. She wants to know why he’s bringing her and Joey into this madness, and Carroll says it will take time but she will love him again. He won’t let her see Joey.
* * * * *
Carroll tells Roderick that the FBI have found the training camp in New York. He suspects Vince, but Roderick says Vince was just making a drop. Carroll punches Roderick in the nose and tells him that he will no longer have the authority to make decisions.
Carroll allows Joey to see Claire. She is overjoyed. Meanwhile he watches a video of Ryan and Molly having breakup sex.
Ryan goes home and finds Molly in the kitchen. She sees that he is stressed and she consoles him.
2009 flashback. Molly tells Carroll that when it’s time to kill Ryan she wants to be the person to do it.
Paul…is that you?
Jacob hallucinates that Paul is alive and emerging from the shower. Jacob goes to the shower and finds Emma’s dead body. She was stabbed to death. Then Jacob wakes up.
Jacob wanders around the Crazy House and sees Joey, who is happy to reunite with him. Jacob ignores Emma when she tries to speak to him and explain why she abandoned him and Paul.
Carroll meets with Jacob and politely asks him to forgive Emma and talk to her. Jacob sees Paul again, who appears and says ‘Emma is a selfish bitch, always was.”
Jacob finds Emma and they talk. Emma says that she’s sorry about Paul and she loved him too. She says Roderick told her to leave with Joey, but Jacob isn’t buying it and he says she could’ve saved them.
Later, Emma tries again to connect with Jacob. She wants him to trust her again and she says that she loves him. They start making out. He is once again haunted by Paul, who says that he is dead because of her. Paul says that Emma needs to die. Jacob ‘kills’ Paul again, and then he tells Emma that he smothered Paul with a pillow. He says ‘I have a real taste for it now. I’d watch my back if I were you.’
– – – – – –
Carroll and Roderick clash
Carroll has two followers who are skilled at hacking the FBI. They are Vince and Brock. They hacked a satellite system and attempted to contact Claire. Roderick wants to leave and do his work as Sheriff, but Joe tells him that he failed twice to get Claire so he needs to skip work and get her.
– – – – – –
Claire, where are you?
Ryan wants to speak to Amanda Porter (from the Love Hurts episode) but the FBI team in D.C. are holding her. Ryan threatens to quit if he isn’t put in charge of Claire’s protection detail and Donovan reluctantly allows it.
Ryan meets at the hotel where Claire is hiding. He tells her about the Claire Matthews saga from the Love Hurts episode. He tells her that she needs to be moved somewhere safe.
Roderick, Vince, and Brock arrive at the hotel. They have found the floor she’s on, and they all put on masks and grab guns. Roderick has a master key that he’s using to open all of the hotel doors.
Roderick finds her room but they are too late. Ryan and Claire escape from the hotel and one of the followers tries to hold her at gunpoint. Ryan says ‘You’re not going to shoot her,” and he shoots the guy. Claire hops in Ryan’s car and they drive off.
– – – – – –
Ryan gets some help
Parker and Donovan don’t know where Ryan and Claire are headed to and apparently they are unable to track her.
Ryan drives to the home of Tyson, a former FBI agent who is now in witness protection. Also, he plays Batista on Dexter!
2005 flashback. Tyson tells Ryan that if he publishes ‘The Poetry of a Killer’ then he’ll always be that ‘Joe Carroll guy’. He thinks the book is a bad idea but he still supports Ryan.
While Ryan is freshening up, Claire decides to ask Tyson about Ryan’s love life. Tyson tells her about Molly, and there’s a 2009 flashback with Molly and Ryan flirting. Tyson tells Claire that Ryan always pushes women away but she is the only woman he’s ever really cared about.
Tyson and Ryan find a chip in Claire’s sweater, and conclude the followers are tracking Claire and they know her location. Meanwhile, the FBI still doesn’t know where Claire is, and they have the bright idea that Ryan has taken her to his home, which was wishful thinking on their part.
– – – – – –
And… they arrive!
Carroll meets Joey in the kitchen for lunch and tries again to talk to him. They make s’mores.
Ryan, Tyson, and Claire are still waiting for the followers to show up. She wants to know why Ryan never called her for 8 years, and she says “What if I said I love you?’ and he said ‘I’d say that’s a really bad idea, and I love you too.’ Then they make out.
Roderick, Vince, and Brock are closing in on Claire’s location. Tyson shoots and kills Brock.
Roderick goes to the front door and yells for Claire to come out. Tyson is shot when he goes outside to find the followers. Claire runs outside and approaches Roderick and Vince. She says ‘Take me to my son’ and she gets in the car with them. They drive off with her.
– – – – – –
Another guest stops by the Crazy House
FBI team find an online portal that looks like a possible recruiting tool or online get-together for Carroll’s followers.
Ryan is at the hospital with Tyson when he gets a phone call from Carroll, who taunts him about Claire. Ryan says that he quits, but we all know that isn’t true.
2005 flashback. Tyson tells Ryan to stop pushing Molly away because of a fictional death curse. Ryan believes anyone who comes around him eventually dies.
A guest stops by to see Carroll- it’s Molly!
The FBI guy standing directly in front of the door and gets shot by Roderick.
Why the hell is Claire asking about Ryan’s love life when she has murderous psychos on her ass?